Lamentations for Tisha B’Av

candles-mourningTisha B’Av begins tonight. Lamentations (Eicha in Hebrew) is read tonight in a synagogue strewn with upended chairs following a meal of lentils eaten alone. These comments on Lamentations are designed to make your reading more profitable.

David Clines, writing in the Eerdmans Commentary on the Bible says of Eicha:

Its theological position is quite subtle: it does not take just one perspective, and it does not recommend a single solution. It begins with the reality of disaster, and it concludes neither with cheap grace nor easy hope but with the bitter possibility that the people of God have now become the ex-people of God, that this time God may indeed have finally rejected Israel (5:22).

Clines does not say the book offers no hope. The hope comes primarily in the middle, in the longest of the five poems (chapter 3), the section emphasized by nature of its longer structure as well as in the synagogue by being canted the loudest. Lamentations is made up of five poems as follows:

1. An acrostic poem (each verse begins with a letter of the alphabet in sequence) of 22 verses.

2. An acrostic poem of 22 verses.

3. A triple acrostic poem of 66 verses, with a passage of hope in 3:22-33.

4. An acrostic poem of 22 verses.

5. An alphabetic but not acrostic poem of 22 verses (the number of verses is deliberate though they do not begin with the letters in sequence: deliberate movement toward chaos?).

The Setting and Authorship of Lamentations
Tradition says this poem was written by Jeremiah. This tradition is late and has some possibility, but no basis.

The poem is set in post-destruction Jerusalem, so it is from 586 B.C.E. or later (the Babylonians destroyed the Temple and the city in 586). Clines observes that the poem could have been written much later as Israel remained in a sort of exile (and still does today) waiting for God’s promises to be fulfilled. P.M. Joyce, writing in the Oxford Bible Commentary theorizes that Lamentations was written right after the disaster and used as liturgy by those who went daily to mourn on the Temple ruins.

We cannot know for sure who wrote Eicha or when. Its themes could have been liturgy for the community right after the destruction, but it could also have been a theological psalm from the centuries after, when the people were still wondering when God would appear. Its themes still ring true today as the wait has lengthened to millennia.

Theological Themes
As Clines observed, there is no singular answer in Eicha. It is a book reacting to disappointment and sorrow. People rarely have a structured or coordinated response to tragedy and Eicha is true to life as a bitter reflection.

There are three notions around which the themes of Lamentations revolve:

1. The supposed indestructability of Jerusalem, the city of God, which has turned out to be a lie.

2. The election of Israel by God and its ongoing relationship and covenantal promises, which are in question.

3. The curses of the covenant which explain the disaster but which are in tension with the ongoing covenant.

Has God chosen? Has he rejected? Have we earned these curses, as the warnings of Leviticus and Deuteronomy suggest? Or have we hope because the covenant is never-ending and larger than the retribution for failure?

Clines suggests in particular five lessons for mourners from Eicha:

1. Grief and self-reflection are legitimate and expression of bitterness is valuable and necessary. This contrasts with the well-meaning but misguided religious notion than due to our knowledge of God, we should be restrained in grief and expression of suffering.

2. God can be held responsible for tragedies. Though Jerusalem’s guilt is evident, still God had a choice of how exacting to be in vengeance.

3. Memories of God’s past kindnesses provide hope for the future, though God is not guaranteed to act favorably in the near term.

4. Repentance is not a tool for persuading God to relent as God is free to act as he chooses.

5. God is ultimately free to reject consolation and return. At least in our timing and according to our desire, God’s covenants do not obligate him. While he will be true, we do not know when or how.

Outline Adapted from Clines

Chapter 1: The Widowed Jerusalem
–The Scene (1-11)
–An Appeal (12-22)

Chapter 2: Adonai’s Anger and the Impossibility of Comfort
–The Anger (1-10)
–The Poet’s Inability to Comfort (11-17)
–A Cry for Mercy (18-22)

Chapter 3: When the Mood Changes
–A Man Who Has Seen Affliction (1-21)
–Adonai’s Mercies Never Cease (22-33)
–What of Repentance? (34-66)

Chapter 4: Casting Blame
–Jerusalem’s Inhabitants (1-11)
–Jerusalem’s Priests and Prophets (12-16)
–Jerusalem’s King (17-20)
–Jerusalem’s Enemies (21-22)

Chapter 5: Expectations of God
–A prayer to God by the community coming to a crescendo in 5:21 and sounding a dire note in 5:22. The end leaves no answer, only grief and longing.


About Derek Leman

IT guy working in the associations industry. Formerly a congregational rabbi. Dad of 8. Nerd.
This entry was posted in Bible, Holidays, Judaism, messianic, Messianic Jewish, Messianic Judaism and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Lamentations for Tisha B’Av

  1. tnnonline says:

    The name “Jeremiah” does not appear in the Book of Lamentations, so denying a traditional authorship does not present any problems, since the text itself does not make this claim. The Book of Ecclesiastes similarly does not claim Solomonic authorship, and all major authorities recognize its Hebrew from a later period in Israel’s history (even though I think a good case can be made for it being pre-exilic).

    I suppose with Lamentations, I have been generally inclined to recognize Baruch as the author. Jeremianic material for certain, but perhaps with a different twist.

  2. Pingback: The Fast of Av « Messianics For Torah

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s