Shmuley Boteach’s Non-Divine, Non-Messianic Jesus

Shmuley Boteach has a book soon to be released about how non-Jews can save Judaism and how Jesus is a prophet, but not divine or any kind of messiah. Judaism is a failure, he says. It’s too tribal. It has no appeal in a world where people want to share life and culture, not remain separate. Jews left Judaism 200 years ago in the Emancipation and they’re not coming back, he says. Read the article on JPost here.

So, Shmuley is showing people a way that is ancient and can be made new: a sort of associate relationship to Judaism like the God-fearers and Judaizers of the Second Temple Period. Ten percent of Romans kept Sabbath, some of the sources tell us. And non-Jews today, says Shmuley, can practice Jewish spirituality in modified forms without giving up their own identity or joining the tribe.

Shmuley’s upcoming book is about Jesus. Jesus the prophet, he says. But not Jesus the divine man or Messiah. Problems? You bet . . .

Before Reading Shmuley’s Book, Here Are a Few Problems

(1) If Jesus is a prophet (I certainly think so) then his words are from God. There is no way Shmuley can believe this. I predict some sort of game-playing will ensure so that many of Jesus’ words will be ignored through either denial of authenticity or clever reinterpretation.

(2) Paul, says Shmuley, needed a way to make Judaism’s God more accessible, which he did by inventing a human-deity that is somehow (Shmuley doesn’t say how) more compatible with Greco-Roman ideas about deity. This does not do justice to the complex and rich Christology of Paul. It’s an amateurish theory at best. Shmuley is entering a well-populated field and I predict he will not interact with the best sources on Pauline Christology.

As for Judaism being a failure and the solution being a revival of the idea of God-fearing gentiles (Judaizers, Jewishly-spiritual non-Jews), here are a few more problems:

(1) How will this solve the problem of intermarriage and the loss of Jewish identity? Will these God-fearers be allowed to marry into the tribe? First, I doubt Shmuley will propose that and second, if he did, this would still mean the loss of Jewish identity more and more over time.

(2) How does this help unify humanity? Jewish identity in Shmuley’s model is still separate. An associate membership in the tribe for non-Jews is not a solution and it unifies nothing.

How About Paul’s Solution?

Want to read just one book that will make you understand all this from Paul’s point of view? Try N.T. Wright’s Justification.

Paul says the solution has been there all along . . . in Abraham! Abraham, the progenitor of Israel is also the source of blessing for every family on the earth, every nation — for gentiles as well as Jews.

And the seed of Abraham — both the corporate seed Israel and the individual seed Jesus — is the blessing for Jews and non-Jews. Here is a way to look at it. Israel was brought in early, through Abraham, into a covenantal relationship with God. But that was never the limit or extent of God’s plan. From the beginning he said it was to bless all the families on earth. Now, that blessing has started in Jesus and will be completed at the turning of the ages. So, the first chosen and those chosen later in Jesus both relate to God in the same way: by faith. Note that this does not erase Jewish-gentile distinction, does not annul Israel’s covenant relationship to God, and does not imply that Jewish followers of Jesus cease to keep the way of Torah.

This is not some late addition to the Abraham story. Both parts (gentiles and faith) were there from the get-go (check Genesis 15:6). Then read Romans 4.

Finally: The Very Prophetic Words of the Divine-Man Jesus

Let me close with a list of some of Jesus’ prophetic words, which I hope Shmuley will heed, since he now says Jesus is a prophet:

Luke 19:40 If these [people calling me Messiah] were silent, the stones would cry out.

Mark 14:61-62 The high priest asked him, “Are you the Messiah, the Son of the Blessed?” And Jesus said, “I am; and you will see the Son of man seated at the right hand of Power, and coming with the clouds of heaven.”

Matthew 11:27 All things have been handed over to me by my Father.

Mark 2:10 The Son of Man has authority on earth to forgive sins.

John 6:35 I am the bread of life.

There are plenty more and you can find much of the material about Jesus’ identity at my Yeshua in Context blog under the category “Identity of Yeshua” by clicking here.

About Derek Leman

IT guy working in the associations industry. Formerly a congregational rabbi. Dad of 8. Nerd.
This entry was posted in Christian, Judaism, Judeo-Christian, messianic, Messianic Jewish, Messianic Judaism, Yeshua, Yeshua In Context and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to Shmuley Boteach’s Non-Divine, Non-Messianic Jesus

  1. I like Shmuley. He’s reduced the divide between Jews and Christians.

    Unfortunately, his book about Jesus-the-prophet-not-divine, being based only on the New Testament, will likely contain impressive Scriptural acrobatics.

  2. drake82dunaway says:

    Rabbi Schmuley is a good-hearted man, but I have a problem with he and Muslims who say that Yeshua was a prophet/spoke for G-d, but denying His claim to divinity. When you make a claim like that, you’re either the Moshiach or a heretic. There is no in-between.

  3. praesto12 says:

    Thanks for the commentary on the book. It seems that anything antithetical to Judaism or Christianity is seen as new, interesting and scholarly. Even if the ideas used to “discredit” Christianity are not new, interesting or scholarly. I’m glad to see you take the time and shoot down a lot of the quasi-intellectual garb that many modern skeptics and like are producing.

  4. danbenzvi says:

    Halleluyah!!! Derek has gone One-Law….We can all drink latte now…LOL!

    “Paul says the solution has been there all along . . . in Abraham! Abraham, the progenitor of Israel is also the source of blessing for every family on the earth, every nation — for gentiles as well as Jews.

    And the seed of Abraham — both the corporate seed Israel and the individual seed Jesus — is the blessing for Jews and non-Jews. Here is a way to look at it. Israel was brought in early, through Abraham, into a covenantal relationship with God. But that was never the limit or extent of God’s plan. From the beginning he said it was to bless all the families on earth. Now, that blessing has started in Jesus and will be completed at the turning of the ages. So, the first chosen and those chosen later in Jesus both relate to God in the same way: by faith. Note that this does not erase Jewish-gentile distinction, does not annul Israel’s covenant relationship to God, and does not imply that Jewish followers of Jesus cease to keep the way of Torah.

    This is not some late addition to the Abraham story. Both parts (gentiles and faith) were there from the get-go (check Genesis 15:6). Then read Romans 4.”

  5. thelordsgoat says:

    I knew R. Shmuley despised the Messiah. What I didn’t realize is that he also despises Judaism. Sadder still, he seems completely unaware of this on both counts.

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s